i knewwwww it! soo scarry i caant wait for the next chapter this was seriously amazing. hhaa i loved the birthday dinner it was soo cutee. i think i know who killed them both but imma keep it a secret to see if im rightt! please update soon!
Author's Response: Thank you! I'm glad you liked this chapter and enjoyed the birthday dinner before everything turned dark :) And you'll find out soon if your guess is right!
poor Lily...im coming up with all these possibilties! oh and btw, u made a small error- you mentioned that there were mince pies on the table twice.. :)
but apart from that, it was awesome as always.. cant wait for the next one!!
Author's Response: Definitely poor Lily . . . I'm glad you're theorizing :) And I'll fix that typo! Thanks for pointing it out!
What? What? a cliffy? Oh thats just great.
Author's Response: I know, it's mean, but the next chapter is already half written and should hopefully be posted soon!
What? What? a cliffy? Oh thats just great.
Oh no!!! Wonderful chapter with a chilling end... POOR Lily!
I think that Grace has something to do with the murders... maybe that is horrible of me, and I do feel sorry for her, but she totally could have put the curse on her boyfriend and some of the things she has said to Lily are suspicious... I also think Regulus might be involved somehow. That would make sense. And Lenore definitely knew something, that's why she was killed.
I love this story, the suspense is killing me! Update soon :)
Author's Response: Thanks for the review! And thanks for sharing your theories -- you'll find out soon enough ;) The suspense is really building, I know, but the next chapter will hopefully be posted soon!
I absolutely love this story. I'm not sure if I've told you that, but it can't hurt to tell you again. It has a wonderful mixture of romance and angst and happiness and mystery and it is amazing.
Since it is probably recommended that I leave critique, there are a few mistakes here and there with word choices and spelling, but I can't find them again..
I really love the plot, too. It is simply..
Author's Response: Thanks very much! Feel free to tell me as often as you like :) And, oh, I also manage to have a few mistakes with grammar and spelling -- if you do find them, please point them out!
NOOOOOO!!!!!!!! Why did she have to die???? She didn't even get to tell James or Lily that thing she wanted to tell them!!!!!!
Oh well. It's a good story! Update soon, please!
Author's Response: It definitely did up the darkness of the story even higher, didn't it? And her secret died with her! I'm glad you like the story. Thanks for the review! The next chapter should be up soon.
Loving your story. You're one of my favorite writers and I love reading your work. I think Peter killed Jilly; her sweater was found in his dorm and I know James, Sirius or Remus did not kill her. It would have been hard for a Slytherin to sneek the sweater into the boy's dorm without the password. Not sure who killed Lenore; probably was the same person who killed Jilly. She knew too much about Jilly's murder, so they killed her to keep her silence. Great chapter; I'm looking forward to your next update!
Author's Response: Thank you! I'm glad you consider me a favourite :) Ooh, I like the theorizing . . . you'll find out soon enough! The next chapter (hopefully!) isn't too far off.
Hello my dear!! I read both of the latest chapters together right now since I couldn't last week cause of my finals )I GOT MY CHEMISTRY REGENTS GRADE I GOT A 68!! haha its a big deal that i actually passed) I beleive that Regulus killed both of them, or well Regulus used the imperious curse to kill Jilly and then finished Lenore off in person to make it offical, I love the cute little Siruis & Lily banter and James had the perfect boy reaction to his birthday as well, I recomended this to my friend and I hope she starts reading too so I can finally share with others how great this story is!
Author's Response: Thanks! Haha, I know how killer chemistry can be -- congratulations on passing :) And I'm glad you liked this chapter -- liked the banter and James's reaction. As for your theory, well, you'll just have to wait and see! Thanks for trying to spread the story love!
"No, I'm Sirius", "I Sirius-ly do"- Jeeez, that made me laugh :'D I LOVED this chapter, talk about suspense! I actually have my suspicions on the murderer, but I wont say anything incase im reeeaallly wrong (: my favorite Lily/James fanfic, but all of your stories are amazing- the romance was perfect and i cant wait for the next chapter!
Author's Response: I'm glad it made you laugh! I'm also nervous about trying to write humour. I'm glad you liked this chapter; thanks very much for the review!
Whoa, you've really upped the suspense level!!
Can't wait for the last few chapters, and really, this has become on of my favourite James/Lily stories every =D
Author's Response: A favourite James/Lily story? That's high praise! I'm glad you like it so much :) Thanks for the review.
Nice! Keep them coming!
Author's Response: I plan to! :)
Nice! Keep them coming!
I don't know if I've ever taken time to leave a review or not, but I have so been enjoying this story. I get very excited when I see it has been updated. Nice chapter. I had a feeling when Lily saw Lenore on the map, and was very glad to see James and Sirius go with her... can't wait for the next chapter!
Author's Response: I don't think you ever have -- but thank you so much for reviewing now! I'm glad you're enjoying the story. I actually wrote Lily finding Lenore by herself and James finding her with Lenore, but that was way too much like Jilly's death, and I think this works much better. :)
DUN DUN DUN!!!!!!! Definitely the same person killed Jilly and Lenore. I think that someone's definitely got it in for Lily's mates. The arguing between Sirius and Lily is really funny, and "she dresses like a ninety-two-year-old librarian" is my favourite line.
You should become a crime writer, your stuff is really good and original work would be even better.
Can't wait for the next update!
Author's Response: Thanks so much! I love reading mysteries, so I'm so glad you think I write it well :) And I'm always nervous when I try to write humour, so I'm so relieved you found their bickering funny!
It was really good! I hope you come up with more chapters soon. Poor Lily, all of her best girlfriends are being killed. Thankfully James is ther to protect her.
Author's Response: Thanks! Yes, hopefully the next chapters will be up soon :) And poor Lily indeed!
This looks really good, I can't wait to read the story when it's finished!
Author's Response: Thanks! It won't be too long before it's finished :)
This is such a cool story. Seriously. On MNFF, I've only been hooked on a few as much as your one. I'm kind of sad that it will only be another four chapters long, but that's OK. Life goes on.
Anyway, besides that, I think Marlie sounds ever so slightly suspicious by not saying Jilly's name - but she's still one of the good girls, and Grace is definitely not a baddy either. I feel sorry for her in a way.
I also loved the way James just left Lily alone when he heard her crying (at least the guy's sensitive). I think nowadays, everyone thinks that girls need a shoulder to cry on, and that's not true. Lily's one of those girls who probably doesn't want anyone to see her cry, because that's just embarrassing.
Finally, I hope you post the next chapter soon. I can't wait!
P.S. I just looked at the lyrics of the song you were referring to in your A/N, and I just clocked on that the lyrics are the names of the chapters! God, I'm so stupid sometimes!
Author's Response: I'm glad you like it so much! I'm a little sad it's almost over, too, but I guess I'll just have to start another multi-chapter Lily/James after :) And I feel a little bad for Grace, too. I'm glad you liked how James left Lily be -- that's certainly what I would want someone to do if I were in Lily's position. Thanks for the review! The next chapter should be up soon.
Keep them coming!
Author's Response: :)